As per Covergirl's website, the Katy Kat Matte Lipstick is described as a "Demi-Matte Lipstick" that is "Velvety Soft and Luscious-Feeling". They also claim that the lipstick delivers a matte feel without being flat or dry.
I found the product at my local Zehrs in the cosmetics aisle, priced at roughly $9 each. There are 11 shades in the lipstick line, with two pinky nudes, two purply nudes, a coral, one bright fuchsia and one slightly darker magenta, a crimson red, a lavender, a darker purple, and a black. With the exceptions of the pinks, reds, blacks, and lavender, all the shades have a more muted tone to them - they aren't quite the in your face true brights like you would expect from Urban Decay.
I swatched most of them in store and ended up purchasing Cat Call, which is a bright pink that reminds me a lot of BITE Amuse Bouche in Pickled Ginger or Radish.
![]() |
Katy Kat Matte in Cat Call |
I'll evaluate the lipstick based on 5 categories: Application & Feel, Wear, Comfort, Longevity, and Packaging.
Application & Feel
The product went on quite smoothly. It wasn't draggy and didn't pull at my lips or skip, like some mattes (looking at you, Urban Decay...) It has a standard bullet shape with a sharp tip for precision. I found it easy to apply precisely, and any mistakes came off with a quick swipe of a tissue.
I actually agree with the majority of the product description - the lipstick did feel good going on. It was surprisingly moisturizing, and I didn't feel like my lips were dried out at all. It definitely is a demi-matte and not a true matte, as there was minimal sheen to my lips after applying the product. However, rubbing my lips together didn't cause the lipstick to pill or crumble, and there was enough slip that the product was comfortable. The lipstick feels like its 3/4 lipstick and 1/4 chapstick. I was happy!
I should also mention that these are scented, because I know that may be a factor for some. It's a generic sweet/candy scent, but its not noticeable AT ALL when you're wearing it. I actually had to bring the bullet to my nose to notice.
Wear
I was really, really impressed by how well this lipstick wore. Usually when I'm out and about I tend to avoid standard bullet lipsticks - I hate how they leave prints on glasses, can smear, and can wind up on other parts of your face and clothing (especially if you're a klutz, like me.) I also don't love re-applying on the go. BUT. These were great! I set out to run some errands and had a 3 hour drive while wearing them. So the lipstick went through heat, sweat, coffee, straws, and a Tim Horton's breakfast sandwich. It coped well!
There was no bleeding or feathering, it mostly stayed where I put it. Straws were no problem - it didn't fade at all. Coffee cups were another story - there was a definite, distinct lip print and a fade of my lipstick. BUT, I didn't need to reapply, and there was a pleasant staining effect left over. My lips never felt dry or cracked, and it was lightly moisturizing.
The ultimate test was my panini at lunch, which necessitated complete reapplication. But, it lasted for about 5 hours and 2 coffees without me having to do so!
![]() |
Swatches in different lighting. Top is several swipes, bottom is one swipe. |
Comfort
I've already mentioned this, but these are VERY comfortable to wear. No drag, but also not much slip, and not drying. 10/10.
Longevity
Again, I've already mentioned it - but these lasted through harsh conditions for about 5 hours. I wouldn't expect it to last through a dinner where you're constantly sipping cocktails and then eating an entree, but through a coffee date, out running errands, or a light lunch these would definitely be fine. And, re-application was easy, so no worries there.
Packaging
Some people don't care about packaging, just about the product inside - but its a big deal for me. I care about the way a beauty product feels in my hand. The Katy Kate Mattes come in a square tube, with a white matte plastic case and a clear base showing the colour. They're very light, especially in comparison to my lipsticks from Bite, NARS, or Lancome. I wouldn't say the packaging feels particularly luxe, but this is a $9 lipstick we're talking about. For the price point, I would say that the packing is great.
There were two things that make me nervous. First, the matte packaging is prone to staining. When swatching the lipsticks in store, I got a little of the orangey-coral on my hands. It immediately transferred to the cap of the lipstick and was impossible to get off. I foresee this picking up eyeshadow, glitter, and foundation in the future for sure. The second issue was thankfully not with the lipstick I purchased, but with one of the testers - when I was taking the cap off, the entire lipstick bullet detached from the based and got stuck in the cap. So use these with a bit of care!
![]() |
Packaging. See the smudges?!? |
Overall...
I don't love the rest of the colours in the range, but I could see myself purchasing one or two more. They're very affordable, and the quality is great for the price. I really am a fan of this collab between Katy and Covergirl! They were comfortable, cute, and felt great wearing them. I would definitely recommend picking these up if you want some fun colours for summer, or even something neutral to wear to the office!